Sometimes the best course of action in Search Marketing is to just let it ride. It sounds lazy, but sometimes it’s the smartest thing you could do. I realize this might not always be a popular option, but there are cases in which doing nothing is the best thing you can do for your site.
We manage Adwords for a client that had an incredibly successful organic position for their number one keyword while at the same time doing everything wrong from an SEO perspective. This is a very old site that earned its authority and trust ranking a long time ago. We do not work on the SEO, but we do manage the analytics and report on overall traffic so it was hard to miss this one. In spite of big mistakes like the home page being titled “Home,” it ranked first for the business’s major keywords. The site has tons of links and authority that helped push it into this position despite it lacking the basics of SEO. Google thought so much of this site that it actually changed the title of the page to be more relevant and even re-titled the site links on the expanded listing.
When we first started working with this client our guidance was to leave these core pages alone! When you already rank 1st for a major keyword with an expanded listing, there’s nowhere else to go so just let it ride… especially if you really shouldn’t be ranking as high as you are. If it ever breaks that’s when you’ll need to go in and fix it, but in the meantime it works beautifully even though it shouldn’t.
Recently someone decided to ignore this advice and re-titled the pages, and… well you can see the aftermath…
This site’s strongest keyword dropped from ranking 1st to ranking between 3rd and 6th, and it switched from the Google generated headline to the newly written title. This new title didn’t even have the main keyword in it! Not good! This caused a roughly 66% drop in visits. Chances are if they would have left it alone we’d still be seeing that same stream of visitors that have been coming in via that word for years.
Is there a chance the site will fight its way to the top? Yes. But will it have been worth it to lose thousands of visitors just in order to get back to the same spot it already had? Probably not. Remember whenever you’re assessing a situation “do nothing” can be a valid answer in certain circumstances!